A Picture of Power and Leadership

At The Center for Leadership Studies, we define leadership as an attempt to influence…and power as influence potential. In that regard, “leading” is the art/act of exercising/leveraging power. Historically the most significant research on organizational power was conducted by French & Raven in the 1950’s. In essence, they identified 5 “bases of organizational power.”

Coercive Power

The leader’s ability to administer sanctions.

Reward Power

The leader’s ability to provide rewards or formal recognition.Illustration of Number 1 Winner trophy with finish line in background

Legitimate Power

The leader’s decision making authority.

Referent Power

The degree of respect and trust followers develop for a leader.

Expert Power

The degree of subject matter knowledge the leader possesses.

Then in the late 1960’s – early 1970’s, two other Power Bases were identified.

Connection Power

The degree of subject matter knowledge the leader possesses.

Information Power

The degree of subject matter knowledge the leader possesses.

 

If you categorize the style/approach options of leaders as “DIRECTIVE – PARTICIPATIVE – EMPOWERING”, and compare the way those leadership styles or approaches have traditionally been integrated with POWER, it would look something like this:

 

 

 

Recently conducted research would suggest the following:

  • While all seven bases of power are still both valid and relevant, Legitimate; Referent and Expert Power are clearly distinguished drivers of all three leadership approaches
  • Coercive; Reward and Connection Power are effectively subsets of Legitimate Power and should primarily be leveraged when employing a DIRECTIVE approach
  • Information Power has taken on a new meaning. As opposed to being defined as a function of “access” it has come to be recognized as the ability to prioritize relevant information

 

 

 

Given the above, we offer the following random thoughts on Power and Leadership for your consideration:

Legitimate Power

  • In Machiavellian terms Legitimate Power is “bestowed upon you”
  • With each promotion you receive (or advance you make) there is an increased level of responsibility, accountability and decision making authority that comes with it
  • For whatever reason, when leaders refuse to use the power that has been given to them, they frequently lose it altogether
  • Leaders that don’t make effective use of their Legitimate Power frequently lose Referent Power as well (i.e. the respect and trust of others)

Referent Power

  • Referent Power is earned, usually over a period of time, “one transaction at a time”
  • How long does it take for someone to earn your trust? Your respect? The answers (of course) will vary but rarely are trust or respect earned “overnight”
  • Conversely, while Referent Power takes time to build it can literally be lost in an instant
  • While all seven bases of power are important, a strong base of Referent Power is essential for any effective leader

Expert Power

  • Expert Power also accumulates over time
  • There is almost no limit to the creative strategies you can employ to increase your base of relevant expertise
  • Expert power certainly includes formal education but is largely defined by a leader’s base of experience
  • A significant component of Expert Power is being able to discern information “worth knowing” from information that is “irrelevant”

APPLICATION CHALLENGE

  1. Which base of power do you feel is your strongest source of influence potential?
    • Legitimate?
    • Referent?
    • Expert?
  2. Identify a tangible action you can take to increase the relative strength of the other two: